Comparison of polymer types

Alginate

Advantage

  • biocompatibility
  • 3D matrix for differentiated chondrocyte function

Disadvantage

  • does not degrade rapidly in vivo
  • loses integrity over time
  • is difficult to control gelation rate
  • its molecular weight distribution is less controlled
  • ionic

Typical application

  • wound healing
  • drug delivery
  • cell encapsulation

Hyaluronic acid/ Hyaluronan

Advantage

  • supports embryonic stem cell differentiation, proliferation, survival
  • provides stability to the extracellular matrix molecules
  • easily degraded by enzymes e.g. hyaluronidase

Disadvantage

  • fast degradation
  • its molecular weight distribution is less controlled
  • photocrosslinking (when modified)

Typical application

  • drug delivery
  • joint disorders
  • viscosupplementation

PEG

Advantage

  • biocompatibility
  • support survival of chondrocytes
  • uniform distribution

Disadvantage

  • limits cell proliferation
  • has no innate biological cues
  • has high permeability that can lead to diffusion of matrix away from the cells and out of the hydrogel
  • michael addition, photocrosslinking

Typical application

  • drug delivery
  • cell encapsulation
  • antifouling surfaces

Referred from: